Whether you’re a long-time local or passing through for only a few days, you’ll want to be sure to hit up the dining spots that truly represent the small town of Gettysburg. Sure there are chain restaurants around town and newer cafes and restaurants that have popped up over the years, but sometimes what people really want is the old faithful spot where the food is consistently good, the staff is consistently friendly and you know you’ll see someone you know or make new acquaintances. If this is the dining experience that whets your appetite, then you’ll love our list of hometown favorites.
Dobbin House
Housed in the oldest residence in Gettysburg, the Dobbin House oozes history and charm. For that reason alone, you’ll want to gather on the small front porch and snap a few photos to commemorate your visit. Make sure you check out the Tavern in the basement for some true throwback to the 1800s. Because it’s winter, I’ll suggest the Baked King’s onion soup, freshly made with beef and a variety of cheeses on top, baked in a “quick” oven to a succulent tenderness and served up hot and delicious in a tureen. Or try the porridge of the day, freshly homemade soup prepared by carefully boiling over coals with no smoke or dirt therein from stirring the fire, served up steaming hot and heartily herb’d in a pipkin. See what I mean? Oozing history and charm.
And if you’re thinking about visiting soon, be sure to contact them for the Valentine’s Brunch Sunday, February 14, from 10 a.m.–2 p.m. in the Abigail Adams Ballroom. Cost per person is $26.95 and reservations are strongly recommended. 89 Steinwehr Ave., Gettysburg, (717) 334-2100
Lincoln Diner
Some towns are just lucky that they have a popular, traditional old-school diner. Gettysburg happens to be one of those towns. You’ll find tourists, college students and locals alike enjoying the ambience and comfort food that make the Lincoln Diner a must-stop option while in town. The proximity to the train tracks makes for a fun experience when a big ‘ole train lumbers past, too. From hearty breakfast options to to-die-for cakes and baked goods, you can’t go wrong. Open 24 hours, this is an ideal spot to hit after the bars close and you’re not quite ready for the night to be over. This type of visit could include some not-so-healthy but delicious pub grub type offerings, like chicken fingers or mozzarella sticks. Coming in for breakfast? Please don’t pass up the French toast, the feta omelet or the grits. And a hearty stack of pancakes never steered anyone wrong. If it’s something light you seek, give the BLT a try. And be sure to try the rice pudding, too, as it’s one you won’t forget. 32 Carlisle St., Gettysburg, (717) 334-3900
The Pub & Restaurant
If you haven’t been to The Pub, add it to your list. You often have to put in some time waiting at the door to this incredibly popular spot, but it’s worth it. If you can grab a seat in the bar, go for it. Completely rebuilt from the ground up after a fire close to 20 years ago, The Pub is nearly an exact replica of what was there before. From the cozy blue booths and stained glass to the brassy bar with tin ceiling, this building surely provides nostalgia for all familiar with it. Be sure to try a quesadilla, the chorizo sliders or a standard Farmhouse burger; this no-fuss, no-muss place can compete with the best of them. If you like a little heat, try the chipotle pulled pork or Italian sausage sub. Wash it down with your favorite microbrew or with a little splash of wine from the Adams County Winery, and you’ll be all set. 20-22 Lincoln Square, Gettysburg, (717) 334-7100
Ernie’s Texas Lunch
Ernie’s is the kind of place where you walk in and feel like family. It’s definitely the “Cheers” of Gettysburg. Take comfort in knowing some belly-rubbing delicious food is coming your way. If you love hot dogs, you are in for a treat. “Two with on one” is the lingo, which means two hot dogs with everything (mustard, chili, onions) on one plate. Or order up “one with” (or “without”) chopped fresh onions, another with chili and cheese and some gravy fries, and you’ll be in great shape. If you’re a scrapple kind of person, please do yourself a favor and order some. You won’t be sorry. Not a hot dog person? Go for the cheeseburger and ask for everything if you dare. If you’re feeling like something a little less heavy, try the chili or the California cheeseburger. The hot ham and cheese is also killer, and you won’t be disappointed. Wanting to stop in for breakfast? Try the two eggs over light, a half order of home fries and toast of choice. Local tip: when Ernie works in the morning, he will make pancakes in animal shapes for the little ones. Now that is catering to your customers. Offering a little something for everyone with a slice of homestyle happiness, Ernie’s is a Gettysburg staple not to be missed. 58 Chambersburg St., Gettysburg, (717) 334-1970
The Farnsworth House Inn
If you are really looking to experience a throwback to Civil War times, your quest will begin before you even enter the building. Be sure to admire the Southern-facing wall, where you’ll see dozens of bullet holes from the Battle of Gettysburg. And inside the restaurant, the wait staff attire will surely bring you back in time. If period fare like Game Pie and Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie sound amazing to you, then you are in the right spot! Be sure to try both the homemade spoon bread and the Jennie Wade bread. Period libations are also on the menu. Depending on the time of year, opt for outside dining or stay in and enjoy a casual meal in Sweney’s Tavern.
Celebrate a romantic candlelit dinner with your sweetheart for Valentine’s Day for $24.95 per person. Reservations required. 401 Baltimore St., Gettysburg, (717) 334-8838
Hickory Bridge Farm
This quaint location in the heart of Gettysburg apple country sets the mood for a hearty family meal before even walking in the door to the red barn restaurant. Hickory Bridge Farm is country dining at its best, with all recipes made from scratch. Favorite family recipes include spiced peaches, oven-fried chicken, crab imperial, corn fritters and warm apple crisp.
From the moment you taste the cold (or hot) apple juice and appetizers, served in an antique sleigh, to begin your dining experience, you will be enamored with this spot’s charm and comforts. The entrees change each weekend, and what farm dinner would be complete without dessert? Bring your appetite for your visit to this down-home Gettysburg favorite. Hickory Bridge is truly a one-stop destination that offers more than dining, with an on-site bed and breakfast, special events like Game Day (cards), live music, a Red Hat Lunch and many more. 96 Hickory Bridge Rd., Orrtanna, (717) 642-5261
- Dobbin House photo: Dobbin House
- Farnsworth House photo: Farnsworth House
- Lincoln Diner and Ernie's Texas Lunch photos: Alexandra Whitney Photography
6 Comments