Americans spend billions (yes, with a “b”) on Halloween candy every year, but as any savvy trick-or-treater knows, not all candy is created equal. Every kid has their own candy hierarchy, ranked from the favorites that are hoarded for months, to the duds that are traded at the first opportunity.

Curious about which brands are Pennsylvania’s favorite Halloween candy? Candystore.com, an online candy retailer, compiled 17 years of its own sales data to figure out which candies are the most popular in each state. Then, it helpfully created an interactive map to show the results. View the number one selections below, and click through to see every state’s top-3 candy choices!

Every State’s Top 3 Candies by Candystore.com

Tell us: what’s your favorite Halloween candy? 

• Feature image: Bigstock
• Map image: CandyStore.com